Monday, January 19, 2009

Lovely News from Milwaukee

One of the good things about living in Milwaukee was that it had its own, independent bookseller, Harry W. Schwartz. There were four locations, and they were all good; all well-stocked, expertly-staffed, pleasant places to shop for books. They had a "give back" program, where you could choose a local charity so that one percent of your purchase would be donated to it (by Schwartz). A pillar also to the community, in other words. They had remainder tables, so you could always find good books at affordable prices. They frequently brought authors to their stores for readings and book launches. And they were pretty good at ordering anything they might not have in stock. Now they're throwing in the towel, after 82 years. No cut backs, no closing of one or two stores--they're going to be gone. Say goodye to this, and much more; say goodbye to a good chunk of quality of life, quality of community in Milwaukee. Money quote from their announcement:
Unfortunately, profound shifts in how people shop and equally great
changes in the book industry left us and many other well-established
bookshops with dwindling sales.
I can't help but think of that recent New Yorker cover showing two doors: at one, a man is locking the door to his bookstore; next door, a woman is signing for a package--it has the Amazon logo on it. That's it in a nutshell, because the past 82 years have seen multiple economic crises, but somehow Harry Schwartz has managed to weather them all. Once again, just as with newspapers (see my earlier diatribes), I think this comes down to not enough people who should know better doing the right thing. Maybe the Amazon crowd really doesn't care. But somehow I hope they feel at least a little bit of guilt today.

Update: I just see that two stores are being taken over by Schwartz managers and re-launched under different names later this spring. One more chance for everyone to ask critical questions of their book-buying behavior; one more chance to start doing the right thing. Yes, this will cost a little, but at this point in the crisis everyone should understand that you can't get good things for free.

6 comments:

monad man said...

Very nice. Thank you. I will try my hardest to frequent the newly managed stores as much as my pocket book allows.

Ruud van Dijk said...

monad man was never the problem (as s/he well knows); and I think today there are very few people who have never ordered a book on-line somewhere; but we need a balance if we're going to have decent places to live and work; good luck

yooperprof said...

Always sad to hear of "independents" closing. These are hard times for booksellers - I recently read in the FT that even "Borders" is doing badly!

Ruud van Dijk said...

I'm sure for people in small, out-of-the way places, on-line book buying is a great thing; but if you have a decent bookstore nearby, that's different. Borders and B&N, that's tricky. I think they've put their share of independent bookstores out of business, but they're still bookstores themselves, and sometimes fulfill important roles in their areas.

yooperprof said...

I go to Borders to buy music - they have a good selection, and I like being able to listen to discs at their listening stations.

Of course, my young friends think that I'm terribly quaint for actually buying CDs.

Ruud van Dijk said...

Music, that's a related, but also different issue. I still go to music stores (and like Borders listening stations, although they used to have more options), but I guess that's really an old person activity now, and perhaps music stores never were the "pillars" of communities the way some bookstores still are. But I recently saw some numbers showing how few people actually pay for the sounds they put on their personal players these days--this can't be good for the people who write, perform, produce, and market music. Wonder how our young friends feel about that ...